
When we compare the present life of man on Earth with that time of which we have no knowledge, it seems to me like a swift flight of a single sparrow through a banquet hall on a winter's day. After a few moments of comfort, he vanishes from sight into the wintry world from which he came. Even so, man appears on Earth for a little while, but of what went before this life or what will follow, we know nothing.
- King Henry VIII / The Tudors
I recently finished watching The Tudors and I love it! Now I know that a lot of liberties were taken with history and events, a lot of characters got changed around to make a better drama or some were completely removed from history in order to make the show more accessible. All of that still doesn't change that it's a great show with interesting characters set in world far more dramatic than any soap you may watch today; history is just way more complex and brutal than anything any author can come up with I believe. In my opinion the show shines because they take liberties with history and authenticity; the creators clearly focused on making the characters accessible to a modern audience with our standards/values on how a powerful, young and beautiful King should look like - something the real Henry VIII was considered in his time but by today's standards he would just be considered ugly, fat and probably uncool.
The fact that I only knew very general things of the history behind the show worked great for me because most of the executions and betrayals I did not see coming and it added a sense of dread when you realize that real plotting in these past brutal times was not based on some master plan but rather on a chaotic mess of wills that caused a lot of innocent deaths. I would also recommend anyone to do like me and read Wikipedia while watching the show to get insight into the real history behind the characters; it really feels like a punch in the stomach when you read many of these tragic fates loosing their heads/lives on a whim in a time that makes fictional shows like Game of Thrones look like civilized times. The show is also smart to occasionally be extremely accurate to history by lifting dialogue and poetry from the real people behind these events which adds a sense of depth to the events.
What I love about the show is how by retelling history in a dramatic condensed way the characters naturally become very grey and multi-layered, for example King Henry is a murdering bastard and has the blood of many innocent people on his hands, yet with others he is this loving, funny and charismatic guy that you really like despite his other murdering side. The other thing I really love is a general liking of these kind of stories, when you follow a whole life from youth to old age and seeing what relationships remain (the reason Merlin 1998 ruled), in the end I really ended up feeling sorry for King Henry because so many people were dead and he was this sickly old man; a contrast that hits you when in Season One he is a very young, positive, idealistic, healthy man. Finally I also want to give the show credit for the handling of the Protestant vs Catholic conflict because I ended up sympathies and feeling infuriated with both sides at the same time.
The Tudors really is a show with many flaws (costumes, inaccuracies, dramatic license with supernatural elements etc.) but at the same time the cast has made these characters come to life in a way that it made me feel extremely sad when the show ended. I simply realized that I would miss Henry, Charles Brandon, Mary Tudor and the others and that if anything is a sign of a show that I can recommend. It's a show that starts of slowly (Season One being the weakest) and just keeps getting better and better with each season. Now I hunger for more shows set in this exciting time period but all I'm left with is The Borgias - The Subway of TV shows and that makes me sad beyond words. So if you're looking for an exciting show set in a time filled with intrigue, backstabbing, a lot of sex and some really touching scenes and moments then you should definitely check out The Tudors. I give you my blessing.